RMS Titanic: Was She Really a Poorly Designed Ship?

Imagine for a moment that it is the spring of 1912. The world is changing at a pace people have never seen before. Electricity is lighting more homes. Telephones are connecting people across towns and cities. The automobile is no longer just a curiosity. Airplanes have only recently left the ground, yet many believe mankind’s greatest achievements are still ahead.

It is an age of invention, discovery, and incredible confidence. Every year seems to bring another breakthrough that makes life easier, faster, and more comfortable. Although King Edward VII had died two years earlier, the confidence of the Edwardian era remained. Science and technology appeared to have answers for nearly every problem. Does that sound familiar?

Buildings were rising higher. Railroads crossed continents. Massive ocean liners carried thousands of passengers across the Atlantic in comfort that earlier generations could hardly imagine. There was a growing belief that human ingenuity could overcome almost any obstacle.

Into that world sailed a brand-new ship named RMS Titanic. RMS stood for Royal Mail Ship. She was the largest ship afloat and nearly as long as three 100-yard football fields. Newspapers praised her size and luxury. People admired the engineering that had gone into her construction. To many, she represented the very best that mankind could accomplish.

Families boarded her with excitement, believing they were traveling aboard one of the safest ships ever launched.

And you know what? For her time, she was.

The passengers were not foolish to trust her. Titanic had an advanced watertight-compartment system and was designed to survive kinds of damage that would have sunk many older vessels. Her sinking required an extraordinary chain of events, damage extending across too many compartments, too few lifeboats, failures in communication, and a rescue ship that was still hours away.

Yet when human confidence failed in the middle of the North Atlantic, another ship answered the call.

Ships had struck ice before the Titanic, and others would strike it afterward. What made Titanic’s collision so unusual was the way the damage spread along her hull. The iceberg did not tear one enormous opening into the ship. It pressed against her side in several places, separating plates and opening seams across six watertight compartments. The total area exposed to the sea may have been only about twelve square feet, but it extended beyond the limits her designers believed a collision was likely to reach. Titanic could survive her first four forward compartments flooding. She could not survive six.

It is easy to look backward and ask why Thomas Andrews had not prepared for exactly this accident. But this was not an ordinary or frequently recorded form of shipwreck. Titanic encountered a combination of speed, angle, ice, and damage that no passenger ship had been specifically designed to withstand. Her loss exposed a danger naval architects understood much better afterward, because Titanic had shown them what was possible.

Titanic’s steel and rivets have been studied extensively, and some researchers believe the iron rivets made certain seams more likely to open. But that does not mean Titanic was a cheaply built or fundamentally weak ship. Her sister Olympic was built using essentially the same methods, survived collisions and wartime service, and remained in operation for more than two decades. Titanic’s construction mattered, but so did the extraordinary force and distribution of the damage.

I would call Titanic’s sinking one of the most unusual documented iceberg collisions, not absolutely unique. We cannot know what happened to every unrecorded wreck, and Hans Hedtoft may eventually give us another comparison. But based on the evidence presently available, Titanic was unquestionably far outside the ordinary.

After everything we’ve studied, Titanic remaining relatively upright is astonishing. She shifted from a slight port list to starboard and later back toward port, but she never developed the catastrophic heel that crippled the Empress of Ireland, Lusitania, Britannic, and so many others. That gave her crew something many sinking ships never provided: a stable platform from which to evacuate passengers.

The more shipwrecks we study, the better Titanic’s design looks. The iceberg inflicted damage beyond her calculated survival limit, yet she remained afloat, powered, lighted, and remarkably upright for nearly three hours. That wasn’t a badly built ship surrendering easily. It was an extraordinarily strong ship dying slowly after receiving a wound no contemporary liner was designed to survive.

Titanic herself proved it during the sinking. Every disaster we’ve studied since then has strengthened that case.