This was one of the tragic shipwrecks, and it happened while she was still 20 feet from the dock. That makes it all the more sad. As we will see, the ship should not have been allowed to carry passengers because of a problem she had all along. She had a narrow hull and concrete decks, which made her top-heavy, especially after lifeboats were added after the Titanic disaster. It reminds me of the sinking of the RMS Empress of Ireland. It was so fast that no one had time to adjust.
The passenger steamer SS Eastland was built in 1903 and spent most of her career carrying immigrants and excursion passengers on the Great Lakes. She was not a large ocean liner, but she could carry thousands of people on short trips. From the beginning, however, the ship developed a reputation for being unstable. Captains and crew members reported that she tended to list from side to side, especially when heavily loaded. Several incidents occurred during her early years where cargo had to be shifted or passengers moved to correct dangerous leans. Imagine that, ok, everyone, shift to the left, we are leaning too far. Don’t worry, we are fine.
The problems became worse after the Titanic disaster in 1912. New safety regulations required ships to carry enough lifeboats for everyone aboard. While the new rules were well-intentioned, the added weight of lifeboats, rafts, and equipment was placed high on the SS Eastland. Since the ship already had stability problems, the extra weight made matters worse. Those lifeboats weighed a little over a ton each. Engineers and inspectors believed the vessel was safe, but concerns about her tendency to lean never completely disappeared.
On July 24, 1915, the Eastland was tied to a dock on the Chicago River. More than 2,500 employees of the Western Electric Company and their families were boarding for a company picnic in Michigan City, Indiana. As passengers crowded aboard, the ship began to lean first one way and then the other. Crew members tried to correct the problem by moving people and adjusting ballast tanks, but it was too late. At approximately 7:30 a.m., the ship rolled onto its side while still tied to the dock. The disaster happened so quickly that many passengers were trapped below decks. In the end, 844 people lost their lives, making it one of the deadliest maritime disasters in American history.
What makes the Eastland tragedy especially haunting is that it happened only a few feet from shore. Rescue workers, police officers, and ordinary citizens rushed to help, but many passengers were trapped inside the overturned vessel. Investigations followed, but no single person was ultimately held responsible. Historians still debate whether the disaster was caused by poor design, added lifeboat weight, management decisions, or a combination of factors. Today, the Eastland is remembered as one of Chicago’s greatest tragedies and a reminder that even a ship sitting safely at a dock can become a disaster when stability problems are ignored.
Some of the people who pitched in and helped. George Halas, long before he became the founder of the Chicago Bears, Halas was a young employee of the Western Electric Company. He was supposed to be aboard the Eastland that morning, but arrived late after being assigned another task. Instead of being a victim, he spent the day helping rescue survivors and recover bodies from the river. He later said it was one of the most horrifying things he had ever witnessed.
Captain Harry Pedersen and the crew of the nearby tugboat Kenosham rushed to the scene. They helped pull passengers from the water and cut into parts of the overturned ship to reach trapped survivors. Several tugboat crews from the Chicago River did the same thing. They acted immediately, often without any regard for their own safety. The Chicago Fire Department, police officers, and ordinary citizens also played a major role. Many people were trapped inside rather than thrown into the river. Rescuers used axes, cutting torches, ropes, and ladders to break into the hull. Some worked for hours in dark, flooded compartments searching for survivors. Others performed first aid on the docks as victims were brought ashore.
Tugboat crews, firefighters, police officers, doctors, nurses, and ordinary Chicago citizens all jumped into action. The ship capsized in only a few minutes, but the rescue effort continued for days. It is one of those moments where you see the worst of a tragedy, but also the best of people.
Some disasters are remembered because people had impossible choices. Others are remembered because people had almost no time to make any choice at all.
Next week, we will be diving into one of the most infamous and complex shipwrecks of all time.
Discover more from Old Steam Ships
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Wow! I’d never heard of this. It’s unbelievable (at first) so many could drown so close to shore in a large city, but obviously they did. Cool-looking ship but it must have been a terrible design to ‘list’ like that. Concrete floors??
If you notice…it’s REALLY narrow…with all of that weight with concrete floors, lifeboats that weighed over a ton each, and the people…just terrible… and of all times…when people were going for a day out.
yeah, it is narrow… was that to make it faster do you think? And while I like the design, it does look kind of top-heavy as you said in there
Well…I didn’t mention this because it would have made it even longer…but while constructing it they shortened it…when they did that they took out some of the wider areas….which wasn’t good of course. Yes…they do make some ships a little narrower because of speed…you are right on that…but they make sure they are not top heavy….concrete decks? Thats a lot of weight.
What an incredibly sad story, Max. Catastrophic events like this defy logic.
Yes…being 20 feet from shore makes it that much harder.
Unbelievable!
Amazing. I never heard of this, but there are plenty of things you tell me about, Max, without my knowing anything other than that. You continue to fascinate me. Thank you
Thanks Arthur…this one surprised me as well… I couldn’t believe they were only 20 feet or so from the dock
Once a ship starts listing it can already be too late.
Yes…and this went on for too long. The new laws about the heavy lifeboats didn’t help either.
Imagine the loudspeaker saying: “Run to the right!” “Run to the left!” over and over again. So horrible 🙁
Oh my, this is so heartbreaking!
Yes it is Dana…20 feet from the shore…
I promise after next week…it won’t be just “shipwreck Friday” lol…I’ll still have them of course but I’m going to bring some ships that didn’t sink in the picture.
Ha! That will be good to mix it up a bit.
Max, I’ve been watching a show on HULU called, “Construction Fails” and it has episodes where giant container ships run into bridges. It’s horrifying but morbid curiosity keeps me watching. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt32362604/
I’ll take a look! Thank you! I’ve been watching every maritime show I come across.
Like I told Dana…I don’t want to be known as the morbid blogger…so what I plan to do is yes…of course I have to go over things like this but I want to go over ships that did great things as well…and didn’t sink. So there will be more of a mixture of the two after next week. I go over a huge shipwreck next week…not counting the Titanic. I’ll also post a song about it from Woody Guthrie on powerpop to tie in.
Max, I think spreading the sinkers with the non-sinkers is a great idea.
On the ships on the show, the ships win against the bridges iirc. I don’t think anyone dies in them either, but I could be wrong, and if they did it is only 1 or 2 people (not that 1 or 2 isn’t bad, but…)
I fear people might get bored with The Olympic (one of my favorite ships) and ships that actually made it. Although she was a war hero and sunk a German U-boat by running over it. Maybe not though…I will say this…I think all of you will be surprised how beautiful these ships were inside as well as out.
Oh I know what you mean by that…because it always could be worse.
I will give it a watch…those are some huge ships!
This was human error(s) compared to Mother Nature. In the end a lot of folks lost their lives. I betcha there were a lot of legit “I told you so” old salts that saw that one coming.
Yes it was man. One official argued that adding those lifeboats were dangerous on that particular ship before it happened…he was ignored as with a lot of people. After next week…I’m going to start featuring some ships that didn’t sink. Maritime is a deep rabbit hole.
I could imagine a couple old timers sitting on the dock having a smoke, looking at that boat and taking bout al the ways it was a piece of shit. When it comes to making $$$ Max, safety goes out the window.
There you go! That was it in a nutshell…the ironic thing was…when that official I told you about warning everyone about the added lifeboats…HE was the one that recommended it for this trip….the same one.
UGH. Yet the poor captain was blamed because he “didn’t handle the ballast in the belly right?”
Yea…it was a chore sailing that ship. You had to keep an eye out on the ballast all of the time…pump water into one or the other to even her up. Every ship, like cars, have their quirks…but this one was crazy.
It was already imbalanced because of the concrete in the top decks. Nobody in their right mind would add heavy lifeboats to it and not expect tragedy. I wonder if huge pontoons installed on it would have helped? You are right, CB, greed neutralizes anything humane.
Another thing Lisa, which coincides with the greeed, it looks to me have that many passengers was a little over the the limit. Horse shit all around.
“a disaster when stability problems are ignored.” Watching the first video, they mention “the filthy Chicago River.” That river is literally a sewage canal today. Not sure what it was like back in 1915. Also, the Chicago River is one of the (few?/only? iirc) rivers whose course has been reversed. Instead of emptying its sewage out into Lake MI, it goes down river and empties out into the Mississippi.
What a HORRIFIC conglomeration of stupidity, greed, idiocy, etc that led to this needless and senseless tragedy. It couldn’t have been planned any better if someone had tried! 844 died just feet from safety. Disgusting. The pic of the guy holding the dead child is haunting.
“That river is literally a sewage canal today” …Lisa I have a story coming up one day that really shows that…to a different body of water with horrible results.
Im so sorry…I didn’t mean to include that picture. I thought I removed it. I agree with everything you said. Those poor people just out for a nice day with their families…this one was rough…being that close to safety.
Max, I know about it being a sewage canal from when my ex tried to travel down it to the Mississippi and on to the Gulf. He had no idea what he was getting into and had to turn back fairly quickly. It’s full of those Asian carp that leap up into the air. They have an electrified grid between the river and Lake MI to keep them from getting in. The river is full of locks and huge ships carrying goods. It’s a blessing he got out of that mess alive and the sailboat intact.
No need to apologize about the picture. The reality is that a LOT of children were needlessly killed that day 🙁
Wow… you know from a firsthand account. That is just awful…he is lucky…those ships have a hard time seeing smaller vessels and many have been wiped out.
Thanks…I just don’t want to shock people…and I won’t do that on purpose. I watched a documentary from the 1990s about the wreck I’m talking about next week. Suddenly at the end they go to an official building with an archive and started going through how the dead were processed…they would take their picture….and they showed babies, children, women, and men…it was horrible Lisa…but…I have to say this to be honest. That made it real…so real to me. Not just a legendary shipwreck anymore. They wouldn’t show that today…and I’ll never get that out of my mind.
I won’t go off on a big spiel, but the turn of the century was a time of runaway industrial innovation, so often safety considerations were left way behind. IE, the automobile was starting to really take to the roads at the expense of horses. All very new and cutting edge, ol’ Dobbin getting left in the dust, state-of-the-art overtakes horse and cart, so to speak.But the petrol/gas/refueling places, with their litter of loose-lidded gas cans were often a struck match, a casually lit cigarette away from being turned into a massive explosive hole in the ground. Sounds like proper ship design was- sorry- in the same boat.
I’ll add my bit/bitch into that conversation too. Concrete decks? Seriously? That’s an accident literally waiting to happen.
I agree with everything you’ve said. In the Edwardian age, they relied heavily on technology. I guess that sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
When they were building her, they decided to shorten it and instead of taking it through another test they made it top-heavy and then with those concrete decks, that was insane. I can’t prove this, but my best guess is they did not want to use expensive teak wood. I could be completely wrong…that is something I never investigated, but that’s my guess. Concrete is cheap teak wood cost you an arm and leg, but the Titanic still has its teak decks still there. There is a reason it’s expensive.
Yep. There is also the fact that wood floats and the fact that concrete is used to sink foundations.🙄
Yea…that point is well taken! I started to read about that wood….and Max had a bright idea of using it on a deck…$70-$100 a foot…no…hmmmm where is the concrete? LOL.
Lol; lay your money down on the concrete and save the trees?!🙄😬
Yes! That’s it! Because my deck won’t sink at sea!
https://theelephantstrunk.org/2026/07/18/my-people/
Oh my gosh!…how tragic…20 ft from the dock and she list and flops! All those lives lost. Interesting about George Halas. I’m sure he never got over what he witnessed that day.
This is a really great passage, “….cargo had to be shifted or passengers moved to correct dangerous leans. Imagine that, ok, everyone, shift to the left, we are leaning too far. Don’t worry, we are fine.”
No. I can’t imagine that. Terrifying.
The thing that got me was the concrete decks…it wasn’t one thing that did it. The ship wasn’t made top heavy…it kept on being added to and it was a narrow ship. They never tested it like they should have. To captain it…you had to be on the ball to empty or refill the ballast all of the time. Which that should have tipped them off. It’s still the single most loss of life in Chicago to this day.
The ship definitely looks odd.
This is such a horrendous tragedy, but the way the citizens jumped to help, without thinking about their own safety, is the best example of what community os all about.
Something like this brings out the best in people…
Feels like concrete and boats shouldn’t mix…
Yes I agree! They probably didn’t want to pay for Teak Wood which is super expensive but the best for ships. The Titanic still has a lot of it’s teak wood left…it’s durable.